Justus Kelley, 31, became the first married woman and mother to win Miss USA when she was crowned at the pageant’s 75th edition in Miami on Aug. 27, succeeding 2025 winner Audrey Eckert. Kelley, who had held the title of Miss Virginia USA 2026, is a foster mother and founder of the nonprofit Foster Footprints, which supports children and families in the foster system.
Her win was possible because the Miss USA Organization changed its rules in 2023 to allow married women and mothers to compete, reversing a restriction that had cost another woman her crown nearly seven decades earlier.
In 1957, Mary Leona Gage won Miss USA representing Maryland. Within about 24 hours, rumors surfaced that she was married with children, which she initially denied. It later emerged that she had married at 14, given birth to her first child soon after, and had a second child at 16, according to The Baltimore Sun. She had also told pageant officials she was 21 when she was actually 18. An official investigation led to her disqualification, and runner-up Charlotte Sheffield of Utah took the crown. Gage said she received hate mail afterward.
Because Gage had already competed in the Miss Universe preliminary round and qualified among 15 semifinalists before her disqualification, Sheffield could not take her place in that international competition, as judging had already concluded.
Gage went on to work as a performer at the Tropicana Hotel in Las Vegas and was reported to have dated Frank Sinatra and former Mr. Universe Mickey Hargitay. She pursued film roles without major success, but continued watching the Miss USA pageant every year until her death in 2010 at age 71.
Kelley has paid tribute to Gage as she prepares to represent the United States at the 75th Miss Universe pageant, scheduled for Nov. 24 in Puerto Rico, wearing a custom black-and-white coat featuring Gage’s image during her travel to the competition.


Add comment