New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani is expected to release a revised plan Friday to close the Rikers Island jail complex, but the plan does not resolve a basic problem: the law requiring Rikers to shut down by Aug. 31 next year cannot be followed, because none of the four replacement jails meant to take its place will be finished by then.
City Hall has reportedly begun acknowledging that the deadline is unworkable. The four “borough-based” jails intended to replace Rikers are all behind schedule, and local community opposition to the projects has continued.
Even if all four jails were completed, they would hold a combined 4,100 beds — well below Rikers’ current population of 6,650 people. Under state law, the city cannot close Rikers until it has enough replacement capacity, meaning the math does not work even in a best-case construction scenario.
As part of Friday’s rollout, the mayor is expected to highlight next year’s planned demolition of Rikers’ North Infirmary Command, a project first announced in June, as evidence of his administration’s commitment to eventually closing the full complex.
Since summer, Mamdani’s team has been meeting with district attorneys to discuss ways to shrink the jail population, including reevaluating bail decisions, expanding diversion programs as alternatives to incarceration, and reentry initiatives for people leaving custody. The city’s jail population has been rising in recent months rather than falling, and the measures under discussion are not expected to be enough to cut the population by the roughly one-third needed to meet the 4,100-bed target.
Rikers’ current population is made up largely of people facing serious charges, including murder, rape and armed robbery, as well as members of gangs such as the Trinitarios and Tren de Aragua, rather than people held for low-level, nonviolent offenses.
The timeline problems mean that construction of all four replacement jails is unlikely to be finished within Mamdani’s current term, and possibly not within a second term if he is reelected.


Add in the fact that the dem government of NYC is in collaboration with the unions, and the timeline and the price will grow significantly before the new jails are done.