A House hearing on Wednesday grew heated as Democratic lawmakers pressed Homeland Defense Secretary Markwayne Mullin over deaths connected to immigration enforcement operations, while Republicans countered by pointing to Americans killed by illegal migrants.
Rep. Pablo Hernandez (D-Puerto Rico) told Mullin that “since these enforcement operations began, immigration officers have fired at people in at least 29 incidents. At least seven people are dead. Renee Nicole Good, Alex FrPretti, Silverio Villegas Gonzalez, among others.” He added, “we are here to talk about threats to the homeland. When the government enters an apartment and [faces] children and citizens, the government is the threat.”
Mullin responded that he could not discuss ongoing investigations but said he could speak to what he called “Angel families” — relatives of Americans killed by people in the country illegally — whose losses, he said, number “by the hundreds.” Hernandez pushed back, asking Mullin, “Does that justify the killing of innocent people?” prompting an extended exchange between the two.
Other Democrats raised similar cases. Rep. Seth Magaziner (D-RI) said that “in Middlesbrough, Maine, a man named Johan Gerero was shot and killed by an ICE agent in front of his wife and his three-year-old daughter.” Rep. Delia Ramirez (D-IL) said an agent identified as Charles Exum “crashed into the vehicle of Marimar Martinez, a United States citizen, a teaching assistant, and shot her five times,” asking rhetorically, “Was he keeping her safe? American safe?” Rep. LaMonica McIver (D-NJ) said that under the current administration, “65 people have died in ICE custody” to date, calling it “historically high.”
Rep. Eli Crane (R-AZ) used his time to turn the focus toward Americans killed by illegal migrants, thanking Mullin “for bringing up these Angel families.” Crane said: “It’s just so interesting how they don’t care about American citizens that have lost their lives to the millions [of migrants] that the Biden administration let in.”
Over the past two decades, at least 1,300 U.S. citizens have been killed by people in the country illegally, according to figures cited in the hearing. Earlier this month, a mother and her two sons were killed when a truck driven by an illegal migrant from Ukraine struck their vehicle.
A Broader Death Toll
Neither side’s tally in the hearing addressed the scale of deaths tied to migration policy during the Biden administration more broadly, including thousands of migrants who died attempting the journey north, migrants killed in unsafe work conditions, and Americans killed by migrants in cities where local governments have limited cooperation with federal immigration enforcement.
Last week, eight illegal migrants died when an apartment building collapsed at a construction site in New York that was reportedly operating without adequate supervision; three of the migrants working there were among the dead. The collapse occurred as New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani continues to oversee a city economy that relies heavily on an influx of low-wage migrant labor alongside federal welfare spending.
The hearing underscored a sharp partisan divide over how to weigh the human costs of immigration enforcement against the costs of years of lax enforcement — a divide unlikely to narrow as both parties head into further legislative fights over border and interior policy.


Add comment