A new economic analysis finds retailers kept an estimated $235 billion in profits from a 2011 cap on debit card fees rather than passing savings to consumers, as the payments industry fights new credit-card fee mandates in Congress.

Follow America's fastest-growing news aggregator, Spreely News, and stay informed. You can find all of our articles plus information from your favorite Conservative voices. 

Fifteen years after Congress capped debit card interchange fees through the Durbin Amendment, a new economic analysis finds that the promised consumer savings never materialized — and that large retailers kept an estimated $235 billion in profits instead.

The analysis, conducted by economists Robert Shapiro and Michael Strain, estimates that the debit card fee cap generated $235 billion in profits for major retailers since it took effect. A Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond survey cited in the report found that more than 98 percent of businesses either kept prices unchanged or raised them after the cap went into effect, rather than lowering them as retail industry groups had promised.

When the Durbin Amendment was being debated, retail trade groups told Congress consumers would see the benefit directly. The National Restaurant Association said the reform would “benefit consumers in the form of lower prices.” A National Retail Federation executive said merchants were prepared to pass savings along through “discounts and other benefits.” The Food Marketing Institute said the policy would produce “significant savings” for consumers.

Small Businesses Saw Little of the Money

The same analysis found that the roughly 150 largest national and regional retail chains captured 42.7 percent of the total savings generated by the fee cap — about $101.9 billion. More than 2.4 million neighborhood retailers with less than $1 million in annual sales, meanwhile, received just 1.7 percent of total savings, averaging roughly $120 per business per year.

The report also found that the cap pushed up costs on low-dollar debit transactions — the kind of frequent, small purchases that make up much of the business at coffee shops, convenience stores and quick-service restaurants.

Industry Group Says History Should Inform New Mandates

This analysis was published as sponsored content by the Electronic Payments Coalition, a trade group representing banks and payment card networks that has a direct financial stake in opposing new interchange-fee mandates. The coalition is pushing back against current proposals in Congress and in state legislatures to impose similar caps on credit card fees.

“The corporate megastores have a credibility problem,” said Electronic Payments Coalition Executive Chairman Richard Hunt. “They promised American families lower prices and instead pocketed $235 billion. Fifteen years later, hardworking Americans are still waiting for their money, while these same megastores are back in Washington asking Congress to do it all over again with credit cards.”

Retail industry groups that lobbied for the original debit cap have not responded to the new analysis. The coalition is urging Congress to reject new credit-card fee mandates, arguing the Durbin Amendment’s track record undercuts retailers’ renewed promises that consumers and small businesses would benefit.

Readers should note that both sides of this long-running fight — retailers and the financial industry — have significant financial interests in the outcome of any new legislation, and each has funded research and advocacy supporting its position.

Add comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *