The 25th anniversary of 9/11 is shaping up to be a clash over who deserves to stand at Ground Zero, as a coalition of family members is demanding that New York City’s Muslim mayor, Zohran Mamdani, be excluded from official remembrance events because of past statements and associations they say dishonor the victims.
A group of relatives of those killed on September 11th has publicly labeled Mayor Zohran Mamdani an “unwelcome guest” and says his record and relationships make his presence an affront to nearly 3,000 murdered Americans. They argue this is not a partisan gripe but a matter of dignity for families who return to that day every year to mourn and to remember.
Giovanni Galante, whose wife Grace Catherine Galante was among the 2,977 victims, has emerged as a leading voice for the petition effort and made his concerns known in interviews with the press. He framed the objection in stark terms about what he sees as a failure to properly recognize the magnitude of the attack and the pain it still causes families.
“Our objection is based on his public record—his failure to meaningfully acknowledge the horror of that day, and his employment of, support for, or association with individuals who have minimized 9/11, defended terrorists, or even suggested America ‘deserved’ the attacks,” Galante explained. That line is the core grievance driving the petition and the appeal to memorial organizers.
The petition has attracted more than 2,100 verified signatures in a little over a week, with at least 300 signers identifying as relatives of those killed on 9/11. Organizers say the response shows how raw the wound remains and how serious families are about who represents the city at a ceremony meant to honor their dead.
https://x.com/nypost/status/2080990783520309621
Families point to a string of public incidents that they say make Mamdani unsuitable for a commemorative role: comments perceived as deflecting blame for extremist violence, appointments of controversial advisers, and endorsements of candidates with troubling public remarks about the attacks. These patterns, they say, go beyond political disagreement and cut into basic respect for victims.
They cite instances where Mamdani reportedly blamed the United States for radicalizing Anwar al-Awlaki, appointed legal counsel who previously defended an al-Qaeda defendant, and backed candidates accused of minimizing 9/11. For grieving relatives, each item adds to a picture of someone whose associations and rhetoric are deeply troubling on a day of national mourning.
“It is a solemn occasion—one that members of this unfortunate group, along with millions of others, continue to honor, remember, and use to say: never again,” reads the petition organized by Galante. “It is in this spirit that we, the family members of those murdered on 9/11, write to express our concern regarding the potential inclusion of Zohran Mamdani in the 25th-year commemorative events.”
Organizers hope the mounting public pressure will prompt the 9/11 Memorial & Museum and city officials to keep Mamdani from participating in the formal program. Their ask is narrow: keep the ceremony focused on victims and avoid any appearance that would divert attention from the day’s solemn purpose.
The controversy intensified after an attack on the Upper West Side, where a man allegedly shouting “Allahu Akbar” stabbed two people, one described as “visibly Jewish,” an incident police treated as a hate crime. Critics quickly blamed the mayor’s recent inflammatory rhetoric about Israel for worsening tensions, arguing elected leaders should calm, not inflame, divisions.
Jewish community leaders and other elected officials publicly criticized Mamdani’s statements about Israel, including his rhetoric about arresting foreign leaders, as contributing to a dangerous atmosphere. Those critics say that when a city leader uses extreme language, it can legitimize fringe actors and heighten risks for vulnerable communities.
The UJA Federation New York issued a statement warning against the climate created when leaders portray Israel as uniquely evil and illegitimate, and that message has fueled demands that Mamdani be kept off official 9/11 platforms. Meanwhile, the mayor’s campaign-era focus on Muslim experiences after 9/11, such as family members avoiding the subway due to perceived hostility, continues to factor into public debate.
For families at Ground Zero the dispute is deeply personal: what they want is a ceremony free of controversy, centered on the memory of those who died and the commitments born out of that loss. They insist that the presence of anyone whose words or associations are viewed as conflicting with that solemn purpose risks causing further hurt.
As the 25th anniversary approaches, this fight over inclusion highlights broader tensions in the city’s political life and raises questions about how public leaders should navigate sensitivity around America’s worst terrorist attack. Families say their fight is about ensuring the day remains sacred to those who lost loved ones and about safeguarding the memory of the dead from political theater.
Add comment