House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries (D-N.Y.) won the internal Democratic caucus vote to become speaker-designate on Wednesday, taking 251 of 262 secret ballots cast and facing no challenger. The vote positions Jeffries to become speaker when the new Congress convenes in January, where he would be the 57th person and first Black American to hold the gavel.
The tally showed that a vocal bloc of progressive members carries little numerical weight inside the broader caucus, even though 11 Democrats withheld their support from Jeffries in the secret ballot.
Seven of those holdouts issued a joint statement saying they wanted commitments from Jeffries on halting Immigration and Customs Enforcement operations and ending what they called “genocide in Gaza.” The statement said they had seen “meaningful progress” in talks with Jeffries but that negotiations were ongoing, so “our vote in caucus today was no.” None of the seven agreed to comment further when asked.
Two of the seven dissenters represent districts in Jeffries’ own hometown of New York City: Representative-elect Claire Valdez, who will represent parts of Brooklyn and Queens, and Representative-elect Darializa Avila Chevalier, whose district covers parts of Upper Manhattan and the Bronx.
Asked how those districts differed from his own, Jeffries did not directly answer, saying only, “The numbers speak for themselves.”
Representative-elect Don Leonard (D-Ohio), who flipped a district President Trump won by 10 points in 2024, framed his opposition in populist terms. “What we need is a commitment from the speaker to get a 28th Amendment passed in 2028, to end Citizens United, end the corruption and call a vote on U.S. military aid to Israel,” Leonard said. “If he does those things, he’s got my vote.”
Democrats Defend Jeffries
Several Democratic lawmakers pushed back on the dissenters. “This idea that Hakeem Jeffries has not earned this is completely absurd. He has worked hard. He’s done everything he needed to do,” said Rep. Marilyn Strickland (D-Wash.).
Retiring Rep. Nydia Velázquez (D-N.Y.), who opposed Valdez’s candidacy to succeed her, said: “My advice to them is take the time to know how this institution runs and what it takes to be successful here.”
Rep. Joe Morelle (D-N.Y.), who served alongside Jeffries in the New York state legislature, said the two holdouts from New York made a mistake. “They’re going to have to answer to their constituents,” Morelle said. “I think they should have been with Hakeem Jeffries who’s led us to this historic majority.”
Rep. Henry Cuellar (D-Texas) was blunter: “It is a small group that marginalized themselves.”
Not everyone saw the dissent as self-defeating. Representative-elect Dan Koh (D-Mass.) said the holdouts simply answer to different constituencies. “They all got elected with very different constituencies. A lot of them have different priorities,” Koh said. “There are things that their constituencies have demanded. And they want to make sure have the audience of the leader.” Rep. Greg Landsman (D-Ohio) added that the dissent may be a deliberate tactic: “They probably chose to do this because it’s a way of lifting up their issues.”
Context from 2019
Wednesday’s internal vote is not the final word. The actual speaker vote takes place on the House floor in January, giving both Jeffries and the holdouts room to negotiate further before then.
The scale of this year’s dissent is smaller than in 2018, when Democrats last flipped the House. Then-Rep. Nancy Pelosi lost 32 votes in the internal caucus election, and 12 Democrats voted for someone else on the House floor in January 2019, with three voting present. “Nancy Pelosi will be remembered,” said Rep. Jared Moskowitz (D-Fla.). “And the 30 people who voted against her will not be remembered.”
Rep. Tom Suozzi (D-N.Y.) said the size of the Democratic majority makes it difficult for any small faction to exert leverage. “With the majority as big as it is, it’s going to be very hard for anybody to try and hold our group of hostage,” Suozzi said.
Jeffries himself struck a conciliatory tone after the vote. “We’re going to work together to find the highest common denominator in order to make life better for the American people,” he said.
Several members of the Congressional Black Caucus celebrated the historic nature of the moment. “I’ve been thinking about (the former Rep.) John Lewis (D-Ga.) a lot this week,” said former House Majority Whip Jim Clyburn (D-S.C.). “This is a very surreal moment for me.” Rep. Nikema Williams (D-Ga.) said, “As a Black woman from the South, having the next speaker of the House to be a Black man means a lot to me.” Rep. Jonathan Jackson (D-Ill.), son of the late Rev. Jesse Jackson, said his father “would be more than happy to see America making progress. This is what the world looks like. This is what America looks like.”


Add comment