Michigan Democratic Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed said in a Sunday appearance on NBC’s “Meet the Press” that he does not believe Israel should maintain its identity as a Jewish state, telling host Kristen Welker that he opposes “ethno-states” as a matter of principle.
“I don’t believe in ethno-states,” El-Sayed said. “I believe in equal rights to peace, dignity and self-determination.”
El-Sayed argued that Israel, established as a Jewish nation in 1948, faces a choice between its religious character and its democratic one. “We’ve been told for a very long time that Israel is a Jewish democratic state, and I think folks are having to choose, is it a Jewish state or a democratic state?” he said. “And I would argue based on our principles that we should always be putting democracy over everything else.”
He said it was “not a far stretch” to ask Israel to adopt a form of democracy more closely aligned with the United States, one that guarantees equal rights, including religious freedom, to all citizens.
“We dignify the fact that, you know, though our skin color might be different, though we may pray different ways, that America and American laws respect us all the same,” El-Sayed said. “The idea that any government that we are supporting ought to uphold those very basic, same ideals is not a far stretch.”
“I just think it’s important for us to be clear about the principles of democracy, the principles of justice, and the principles of equal rights to peace, dignity, and self-determination for Palestinians and Jewish Israelis alike,” he added.
Pressed on consistency
Welker pointed out that 43 countries today identify officially with a particular religion, including Pakistan, an Islamic republic, and Denmark, a constitutionally Christian nation. She asked El-Sayed why he singled out Israel’s national identity for criticism.
“Well, I don’t believe in ethno-states generally,” El-Sayed responded. “I don’t think we should be in the business of funding the military of Pakistan either. I’m just trying to apply my ideals evenly.”
Rabbi Yaakov Menken, executive vice president of the Coalition for Jewish Values, pushed back in a statement to Fox News Digital, arguing El-Sayed was inconsistent in his focus.
“El-Sayed claims that he doesn’t believe in ‘ethnostates,’ but only attacks the one country in the Middle East that provides the equal rights to peace, dignity, and self-determination that he claims to support. He conveniently forgets that 77% of Palestine is today’s Jordan — which receives billions of dollars of U.S. aid, has been entirely ethnically cleansed of Jews since 1948, and which maintains racist laws even today that exclude Jews from regaining citizenship there.”
El-Sayed, a vocal supporter of the Free Palestine movement, also argued that generations of Palestinian families have been denied a state of their own. “I just think it’s important to remember that there are also Palestinian people whose families have been in the Holy Land for generations and those folks have been told that they are going to have a state of their own only to watch as the Israeli state is expanding, and we are supporting it,” he told NBC.
In an earlier interview with The Atlantic last week, El-Sayed said concerns about his comments reflected “discomfort” rather than any genuine safety threat. “If it is your sense of your discomfort and/or fear of safety that has to keep me quiet while I watch 70,000 people get killed, their homes annihilated, their hospitals destroyed, their universities decimated, and I can’t critique that, then I think what you’re telling me is that their humanity matters less than yours, and I’m not going to be OK with that,” he said.
Fox News Digital said it had reached out to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s office for comment.


Add comment