A Salt Lake County jury has convicted two men of first-degree felony murder in the 2024 killing of an 18-year-old Eritrean refugee who was dragged from his car and shot at a popular hiking trailhead in Holladay, Utah.
A Third District Court jury on Friday found Mateo Heriberto Martinez, 23, and Alex Ruiz-Martinez, 21, guilty in the death of Naod Welday. Jurors also determined the men were acting to further a street gang, triggering a gang enhancement on every count against them. Both were convicted as parties to the offense, a legal standard in Utah that allows for a murder conviction based on encouraging or assisting a crime rather than carrying it out directly.
The killing took place in the early hours of Aug. 3, 2024, at the Mount Olympus trailhead. Welday and two friends were standing outside his car when two men approached and asked whether the group had gang affiliations. One of the men struck a friend identified only as A.A., who fled and hid in a nearby neighborhood. A.A. later told deputies he saw two cars creeping through the streets as if searching for him.
Still holding the car keys, A.A. called another friend and told him to lock himself inside the Hyundai with Welday. At 4:20 a.m., Ruiz-Martinez sent a message reading, “yo hurry up, come to the view.” Three minutes later, Welday called 911.
Between six and eight men then smashed the car’s windows and climbed inside. The 911 recording captured the pounding, breaking glass and screaming, followed by gunshots. Welday was shot and killed in the driver’s seat. The second friend was struck in the head with a hard object but managed to escape.
Investigators lifted a palm print from one of the broken windows that matched a juvenile documented as a member of Florencia 13, a street gang federal prosecutors in Utah describe as affiliated with the Sureños, which in turn pays tribute to the Mexican Mafia, or “La Eme.” Gang investigators found social media images placing the juvenile at the trailhead repeatedly over the course of that summer, and phone records placed Martinez and Ruiz-Martinez at the scene as well.
Salt Lake County District Attorney Sim Gill said the three friends who were attacked “came to America as refugees in search of a better life.” Welday, he said, had been “simply trying to enjoy the view of the Salt Lake Valley.”
Five people in total were charged in connection with the killing. The juvenile with the matching palm print was convicted of murder earlier this year at a bench trial, after a judge declined to move his case to adult court. Two more defendants, Christian de la Rosa, 19, and Joshua Arthur Mielke, 18, are awaiting trial, with hearings scheduled for December. Three additional people face obstruction charges for allegedly helping conceal a vehicle linked to the attack.
Martinez and Ruiz-Martinez are scheduled to be sentenced on Jan. 14, 2027. When arrests were first made in 2024, police said the victims had no gang ties of their own.


Add comment