A Harvard economics paper finds that temporary high-skill visa programs, including H-1B, cut American computing and engineering graduates' earnings by as much as 17 percent, totaling roughly $47 billion a year in lost wages.

Follow America's fastest-growing news aggregator, Spreely News, and stay informed. You can find all of our articles plus information from your favorite Conservative voices. 

A new economic analysis from Harvard economist George Borjas concludes that decades of temporary high-skill visa programs, including the H-1B, have substantially reduced earnings for American workers in computing and engineering fields — the very fields Congress claimed the programs were meant to fill a shortage in.

Congress created the modern H-1B program in 1990 with an annual cap of 65,000 new hires, intended as a temporary fix while American workers trained up to meet demand for tech talent. That cap has never applied to visa extensions, meaning the population of H-1B holders in the country has grown well beyond the headline numbers. There is no official, regularly updated count of how many people are working under H-1B status at any given time. The last formal estimate from U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services put the figure at about 583,000 as of September 30, 2019. The pro-immigration group FWD.US has estimated the number could be as high as 730,000.

Borjas’s research looks at the broader temporary high-skill workforce — H-1B holders, foreign graduates on Optional Practical Training, and intracompany transferees — and measures its effect on wages for American graduates.

The Numbers

According to the paper, American workers with master’s degrees who majored in computing earned 15.8 percent less in 2024 than they would have without these temporary high-skill immigration programs. Workers with master’s degrees in electrical and computer engineering saw an earnings shortfall of 17.2 percent.

Borjas sorted college graduates into 60 groups by degree level and undergraduate major, then ranked them by how much their exposure to temporary workers grew between 2012 and 2024. Among the most exposed third of groups, the number of temporary workers per 100 Americans in that group’s 2010 workforce doubled, from 28 to 56. Among the least exposed third, it rose only from two to four.

The wage effects tracked closely. Between 2012 and 2024, native college graduates in the most-exposed third saw average real earnings fall about 7 percent, while those in the least-exposed third saw earnings rise nearly 6 percent.

Averaged across all native bachelor’s and master’s graduates in science and engineering, Borjas estimates 2024 earnings were 3.5 percent lower than they would have been without the programs — but that average masks concentrated damage in computing and engineering majors, where losses ran 16 to 17 percent.

Even accounting for potential gains to workers whose skills complement additional foreign labor, Borjas calculates that American master’s graduates in computing still lose about $21,000 a year on net, and those in electrical and computer engineering lose about $25,000. Across roughly 13 million Americans in medium- and high-exposure groups, the net annual loss comes to approximately $47 billion.

A Shortage That Never Closes

The program’s defenders have long argued a shortage of qualified American tech workers justified bringing in foreign labor. Borjas’s findings suggest the opposite dynamic may be at work: by suppressing pay in these fields, the programs may have discouraged Americans from pursuing them in the first place.

Borjas also finds that Americans most exposed to competition from temporary workers became less likely to work full-time year-round, and more likely to return to school or shift into government and nonprofit jobs — evidence that workers already in these fields respond to reduced financial rewards by leaving or scaling back.

The research arrives as artificial intelligence begins automating significant amounts of coding work, raising questions about whether the decades-old claim of a chronic programmer shortage will finally be tested against reality — just as the underlying wage data comes into view.

Add comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *